A high water mark is a reference level used to calculate a fund manager's performance fee. Under a typical arrangement, the investor must recover prior losses before performance fees resume, subject to the fund's terms. The provision does not prevent investment losses or eliminate management fees and other expenses.
Hedge funds typically charge two kinds of fees: a management fee based on assets and a performance fee, or incentive fee, based on gains. The high-water mark applies only to the performance fee. Here's how it is calculated, what it protects against, how it differs from a hurdle rate, and which fund terms can change how it works.
What Is a High-Water Mark?
A high-water mark is the prior net value, after fees, above which a manager can charge a performance fee. With a high-water mark, the manager generally earns a performance fee only on gains above that level.
Which value counts as the mark depends on the fund's terms. It is typically the net value at the last date a performance fee was calculated and locked in, adjusted for any contributions and withdrawals, rather than every temporary peak an account reaches between calculation dates. The fund's documents govern how and when it is measured.
The purpose is that an investor shouldn't pay a performance fee twice on the same gains. If a fund loses money, the manager generally has to recover those losses before charging a performance fee again.
Are you a financial advisor? See how the Crystal platform works.
How Is a High Water Mark Calculated?
Under the simplified assumptions below, performance fee = fee rate × gains above the applicable high-water mark. Each time a performance fee is charged, the high-water mark increases to the new post-fee value. If the investment falls, no performance fee is charged until it climbs back above that mark.
Illustrative example
An investor puts $100 into a hypothetical fund with a 20% performance fee and a high-water mark. The example assumes performance fees are calculated and locked in (crystallized) once a year, no management fees, no hurdle, no additional contributions or withdrawals, and no contractual reset.
| Gross return | Value before fee | High-water mark | Performance fee | Value after fee | New high-water mark | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | +20% | $120.00 | $100.00 | $4.00 | $116.00 | $116.00 |
| Year 2 | -18% | $95.12 | $116.00 | None | $95.12 | $116.00 |
| Year 3 | +16% | $110.34 | $116.00 | None | $110.34 | $116.00 |
| Year 4 | +12% | $123.58 | $116.00 | $1.52 | $122.06 | $122.06 |
In year 3, the investment gains 16%, but its value ($110.34) is still below the $116.00 high-water mark, so the investor pays no performance fee. In year 4, the fee applies only to the $7.58 gained above the $116.00 mark: 20% × $7.58 = $1.52. The mark then increases to the new post-fee value of $122.06.
What Does a High Water Mark Protect Against?
Without a high-water mark, a manager could earn performance fees on the same gains more than once, simply by recovering earlier losses.
In the example above, a fund without a high-water mark would have charged a performance fee on the year 3 gain, even though the investor was only recovering ground lost in year 2. A high-water mark helps align the manager's incentive fee with the investor's actual net gains over time.
It's not a complete safeguard, though. Management fees are still charged when a fund is below its high-water mark, and some investors note that a fund deep below its mark may face pressure as the manager works without incentive fees. The high-water mark also applies to the investor's own account: someone who invests at a different time can have a different mark than another investor in the same fund.
What Is the Difference Between a High Water Mark and a Hurdle Rate?
The two provisions answer different questions. A high-water mark addresses whether prior losses have been recovered; a hurdle establishes a return threshold used in the performance-fee calculation. A hurdle is not a guaranteed return.
| High-water mark | Hurdle rate | |
|---|---|---|
| What must be exceeded | The applicable prior net value, as defined in the fund's terms | A minimum return, either fixed (for example, 5%) or tied to a benchmark or cash rate |
| Protects against | Paying fees twice on recovered losses | Paying fees on modest returns an investor could earn elsewhere |
| Where it appears | Hedge fund performance-fee terms | Some hedge fund performance-fee terms; private equity uses a related but different concept, the preferred return, within a distribution waterfall |
Some funds use both. Private equity funds use preferred returns and distribution waterfalls, which govern distribution priorities and profit sharing; they are not a direct substitute for a high-water mark. They are explained in our article on hurdle rates, preferred returns and catch-ups.
Which Fund Terms Can Change How a High Water Mark Works?
High-water mark provisions vary, and the details determine how much protection they actually provide.
- Crystallization period. Crystallization is the point at which a performance fee is calculated and locked in, such as quarterly or annually. More frequent crystallization can mean fees are charged on gains that are later lost.
- Upward adjustments vs. contractual resets. After a fee is charged, the mark ordinarily increases to the new post-fee value. That is different from a contractual reset or expiry, which some funds allow after a period of time or under certain conditions and which can let fees resume before earlier losses are fully recovered.
- Loss carryforward. Whether losses from one period, or on one portion of an investment, count against future gains before a fee is charged.
- Contributions and withdrawals. The mark may be adjusted when an investor adds or withdraws money, so that changes in invested capital aren't treated as investment gains or losses.
- Equalization and series accounting. Methods for charging investors fairly when they enter at different times. Equalization uses credits or adjustments so each investor pays fees only on their own gains; series accounting issues a separate class of interests for each entry date, each with its own high-water mark.
- Interaction with hurdles. Whether the fund also applies a hurdle, and whether it is "hard" or "soft."
- Redemptions. What happens to the high-water mark if an investor redeems and later reinvests.
Questions to Ask a Hedge Fund Manager
- Does the fund use a high-water mark? Is it measured per investor, per series or at the fund level?
- How often do performance fees crystallize?
- Can the high-water mark ever reset? Under what conditions?
- Is there a hurdle rate in addition to the high-water mark?
- Is the high-water mark calculated after management fees and expenses?
- How do contributions and withdrawals affect the mark?
- Can losses expire, or can the reference level be reduced, before they are recovered?
- What are the full fee terms, including the management fee and any pass-through expenses?
Conclusion
A high-water mark is a simple idea with real consequences: under typical terms, it is designed so investors pay performance fees on new gains, not on the recovery of past losses. It does not prevent losses or reduce management fees. Because the details vary from fund to fund, it's worth reading the provisions closely, alongside the hurdle rate, crystallization schedule and full fee terms, before comparing hedge funds.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a high-water mark in a hedge fund?
A high-water mark is a reference level used to calculate a manager's performance fee. Under a typical arrangement, the investor must recover prior losses before performance fees resume, subject to the fund's terms. It does not prevent losses or eliminate management fees and other expenses.
How is a high-water mark calculated?
In a simplified case, the performance fee equals the fee rate times gains above the applicable high-water mark. Each time a performance fee is charged, the mark increases to the new post-fee value. If the investment then loses money, no performance fee is charged until its value climbs back above the mark. Fee calculation dates, contributions and withdrawals, and the fund's terms can change the result.
What is the difference between a high-water mark and a hurdle rate?
They answer different questions. A high-water mark addresses whether prior losses have been recovered before a performance fee is charged. A hurdle rate sets a return threshold, either fixed or tied to a benchmark, used in calculating the performance fee; it is not a guaranteed return. Some funds use both.
Do investors pay fees when a fund is below its high-water mark?
Investors generally don't pay performance fees while a fund is below its high-water mark, but management fees and other expenses usually continue to be charged, and the investment can still lose value.
Can a high-water mark reset?
The mark ordinarily increases to the new post-fee value after a performance fee is charged. Separately, some funds allow a contractual reset or expiry after a set period or under certain conditions, which can allow performance fees to resume before past losses are fully recovered. Investors should check the fund's offering documents.
About the examples: All figures in this article are hypothetical, made-up returns chosen to illustrate how a high-water mark works. They do not represent the actual or expected performance or fee terms of any investment, fund, manager or Crystal Portfolio.
